England's World Cup Right-Back Dilemma: Spence, Rice, or James vs Mexico?

England's World Cup Right-Back Dilemma: Spence, Rice, or James vs Mexico?

Ahmad Fauzi
Ahmad Fauzi
Published: Jul 02, 2026

The Three Lions have a mammoth World Cup clash against Mexico.

England survived a genuine scare against DR Congo, but the drama is far from over. Now, Thomas Tuchel faces his toughest tactical test yet: solving the right-back riddle ahead of a monumental World Cup clash against co-hosts Mexico.

Key Match Previews

  • England scraped through to the Round of 16 thanks to Harry Kane's crucial brace against DR Congo.
  • A formidable challenge awaits against Mexico at their notorious Azteca Stadium fortress.
  • The right-back position is a major headache for manager Thomas Tuchel with injuries piling up.
  • Debate rages: Should Djed Spence keep his spot, or will Declan Rice shift wide?

Kane's Heroics & Mexico's Mountain

It took Harry Kane's clinical 11-minute brace to pull the Three Lions from the brink. Trailing for much of the game, England showed resilience, but the performance highlighted underlying vulnerabilities. Now, they must elevate their game significantly.

The upcoming Round of 16 clash against Mexico is arguably the biggest test of the Thomas Tuchel era. Playing at the intimidating Azteca Stadium, Mexico boasts an exceptional home record, making this an uphill battle for England.

The Right-Back Conundrum: A Tactical Nightmare for Tuchel

England's right-back spot has become an unexpected injury hotbed, forcing Tuchel into uncomfortable decisions. With Reece James battling fitness and Jarell Quansah sidelined since the Panama game, options are dwindling fast.

Spence Under Scrutiny

Djed Spence stepped in for the DR Congo match but endured a tough outing. The Tottenham Hotspur defender was heavily criticized for his role in their opponents' opening goal and didn't complete the full 90 minutes, raising serious questions about his defensive reliability on the biggest stage.

Could Rice Be the Answer?

Following Spence's substitution, Declan Rice was shifted to right-back, a move that surprised many but offered stability. This tactical tweak has fueled speculation that the midfield anchor could potentially start in a defensive wide role against Mexico, offering a more secure option.

James's Race Against Time

All eyes are now on Reece James, whose potential return could alleviate much of Tuchel's stress. The Chelsea star offered a hopeful, albeit brief, update on his condition: "It's OK. I'm feeling good." This suggests a recovery is progressing well.

Thomas Tuchel himself commented on the injured duo before the last match, stating they were "getting closer and closer." While Quansah might be slightly ahead in his recovery, the manager is clearly optimistic about James rejoining the squad if England progresses further. His return would be a massive boost.