Everton's Derby Heartbreak: Branthwaite Injury Rocks Toffees

Everton's Derby Heartbreak: Branthwaite Injury Rocks Toffees

Ahmad Fauzi
Ahmad Fauzi
Published: Apr 19, 2026

Everton suffered a devastating blow during their dramatic Merseyside derby defeat to Liverpool, as star defender Jarrad Branthwaite was stretchered off in tears with a suspected recurrence of a hamstring injury. The 23-year-old left the pitch late in the game, leaving manager David Moyes deeply concerned about his long-term availability.

Key Points:

  • Everton suffered a heartbreaking, late derby defeat against Liverpool.
  • Key defender Jarrad Branthwaite exited the match in the 87th minute with a suspected hamstring injury.
  • Manager David Moyes expressed significant concern over the severity and potential recurrence of the injury.
  • The setback casts a major shadow over Everton's push for a coveted European qualification spot.

Derby Day Agony: Late Goal and Branthwaite's Fallout

Goodison Park witnessed a rollercoaster of emotions. With the score precariously poised at 1-1 after Mohamed Salah's opener and Beto's equalizer, the tension was palpable. Then, in the 87th minute, disaster struck as Jarrad Branthwaite went down clutching his right hamstring, forcing his withdrawal. His replacement, Michael Keane, could only watch as Virgil van Dijk powered home a winning header in the tenth minute of stoppage time, sealing a bitter defeat for the Toffees.

Moyes' Grim Assessment on Branthwaite's Future

Post-match, manager David Moyes offered little comfort regarding Branthwaite's condition. "I'm worried that it could be, might not be great but we'll see," he admitted, his concern evident. This immediate reaction suggests the club fears a serious issue, potentially sidelining one of their most promising talents for an extended period.

The Recurring Nightmare: Hamstring Concerns Deepen

The timing of this injury is particularly cruel for Branthwaite. The young centre-back has endured a stop-start season, managing just six Premier League appearances and 681 minutes of action. He previously missed 23 matches between August and January due to a similar issue, undergoing surgery on his right hamstring.

Expert Insight: A Known Problem

Former Everton set-piece coach Charlie Adam weighed in on the situation, highlighting the ongoing concern. "It looks like that right hamstring again where he had that surgery earlier in the season," Adam told talkSPORT. "If it's that hamstring again it's a bitter blow for him because he's a top young talent." This insider perspective underscores the severity, suggesting a deep-seated vulnerability for the defender.

European Dreams Hang in the Balance

The defeat leaves Everton in 10th position with 47 points, just one point shy of sixth-placed Chelsea. While European qualification remains a mathematical possibility with five games left, Branthwaite's absence could be a critical blow. The club now anxiously awaits medical scan results to determine the extent of the damage and to plan their defensive strategy for the crucial run-in. Their next challenge sees them travel to the London Stadium to face West Ham next weekend.