VAR Chaos! Man Utd's Controversial Goal Shakes Premier League

VAR Chaos! Man Utd's Controversial Goal Shakes Premier League

Ahmad Fauzi
Ahmad Fauzi
Published: May 17, 2026

Matheus Cunha's goal to put Manchester United 2-1 up against Nottingham Forest was allowed to stand despite VAR

VAR Chaos! Man Utd's Controversial Goal Shakes Premier League

The Premier League was rocked by another VAR storm as Manchester United secured a contentious 3-2 victory over Nottingham Forest, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning the very essence of officiating. A goal awarded to the Red Devils ignited fierce debate, overshadowing a thrilling contest.

Key Points:

  • Manchester United's second goal against Nottingham Forest was awarded despite a clear handball in the build-up.
  • Referee Michael Salisbury controversially overruled VAR's recommendation to disallow the goal.
  • Pundit Gary Neville voiced his disbelief, calling the decision "a shocker."
  • Bruno Fernandes equaled the **Premier League** single-season assist record with his 20th.

The VAR Verdict That Stunned Old Trafford

The flashpoint occurred in the 55th minute when Bryan Mbeumo appeared to control the ball with his arm before it fell to Matheus Cunha, who fired home to put Manchester United 2-1 up. Initially, the goal was given, but VAR intervened, directing referee Michael Salisbury to the pitchside monitor.

After a lengthy review, the consensus among observers was that the goal would be chalked off. However, in a move that stunned players and fans, Salisbury announced his decision to stand by the original call, declaring the handball "accidental." The **Premier League Match Centre** later confirmed this, stating: "After review, the decision of goal stands because the handball offence is accidental, therefore the final decision is goal."

Gary Neville's Outrage & Forest's Fury

The decision immediately drew a furious reaction from the Nottingham Forest players and manager Vitor Pereira. Their protests were echoed by former **United** captain and Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville, who was left utterly baffled.

"There is a clear handball... I would be surprised if this stands," Neville exclaimed on commentary. "Honestly, I just don't think that's a goal. It is a clear handball. That is a shocker in every way! Honestly, that is ridiculous. I can't believe what I have just seen." His outspoken criticism highlighted the widespread disbelief at Salisbury's choice to overrule VAR's clear guidance.

A Thrilling Match Beneath the Controversy

Despite the VAR storm, the match itself was a pulsating affair. Luke Shaw had given **United** an early lead in the fifth minute. However, **Morato** quickly equalized for **Forest** in the 52nd minute, setting the stage for Cunha's controversial goal just two minutes later.

Later, Mbeumo extended United's lead to 3-1, sweeping home a cross from captain **Bruno Fernandes**. Yet, **Nottingham Forest** refused to lie down, with **Morgan Gibbs-White** restoring hope by making it 3-2 with a superb finish just three minutes later. Ultimately, **United** held on for a crucial victory.

Bruno Fernandes Chasing Premier League History

Beyond the officiating drama, **Bruno Fernandes** delivered a masterful performance. His assist for Mbeumo's goal marked his 20th in the **Premier League** this season, a remarkable feat that sees him draw level with legends like **Kevin De Bruyne** and **Thierry Henry** for the single-season record.

The Portuguese playmaker now stands on the cusp of making history. With one final game against Brighton, Fernandes will be desperate to register one more assist and become the only player in **Premier League** history to reach 21 assists in a single campaign.

United's Season Climax

The hard-fought win confirms **Manchester United** will finish third in the **Premier League** this season, a solid return for Erik ten Hag's side. They still have a chance to break the 70-point barrier if they secure a victory against **Brighton** away from home on the final day of the campaign next Sunday. All eyes will be on the south coast as **United** aims to finish strong and Fernandes eyes his place in the record books.